Not so surprising. They are only vampires after all, and vampires have lost most of their mystique in recent years. Even zombies and demons are relatively ho-hum and cthulhoid minions are just simply squamous (if you ignore the sanity-degrading effects of poly-dimensional creatures).

What you need for true horror is probably something like the denizens of Kult. That's a game that still makes me uncomfortable even reading some of the scenarios in broad daylight.

And promises, promises...